Although I’m not a person who would typically be described as being ”crafty” (as in crafts, not sneaky), I used to love making our annual Christmas and Hanukkah cards. Ever since our twins were toddlers, The Spouse and I have been making different Christmas cards (in the shapes of ornaments, sometimes with decorative fabric ribbons, or vellum overlays) and including a short, funny story to serve as an antidote to the traditional family holiday letter where folks recount the previous 12 months’ events. Our Christmas card stories usually got laughs at our, or our kids’, expense.
But over the past two years, this Christmas card business has become a source of contention in my house. Why? Because I’m no longer allowed to write about anything that’s truly comedic because the kids say it embarrasses them. It’s one thing to write about our lives in this space where I don’t mention the kids’ names or post their photos. But it’s quite another thing, they maintain, to write a funny anecdote about them, attach their photos, and send them out to all of our family members, friends and neighbors, including kids with whom they attend school.
For the past few weeks, I’ve been trying to come up with a topic that would: a) Be funny and b) Be acceptable to the Picket Fence Post family.
The story about The Spouse trying to prove he’s not middle-aged when he hopped up on the kids’ Rip Stick . . . and then fell flat on his back in the driveway, prompting the kids to fetch me so I could help him up? To make it funny, we were worried that it might come across as too mean. People who don’t get my sense of humor might pick up the phone and inquire about why I was being cruel to my husband and suggest it was un-Christmasy, maybe offer up a phone number for a couples therapist.
The story about The Youngest Boy plunging into mourning after we sold our tan mini-van (called “The Funny Van” since we got it seven years ago), complete with sobbing and angrily lashing out against our new family vehicle? The Youngest Boy got very upset at the prospect of me writing something like that. Then he told us, AGAIN, how much he missed the mini-van and was still angry we got rid of it.
The series of Q&A’s I did with the three kids where I asked them a variety of questions about their current likes and dislikes, with plans to excerpt the best parts on a card insert? The Spouse said it wasn’t funny enough. Nor was it cutesy enough. It was just kind of blah, he said.
The anecdote about The Spouse and the children telling me I couldn’t take a walk down the street to the park with them unless I fixed my hair (because it was “embarrassing” piled up on top of my head and “sticking out”) which prompted me to don Groucho Marx glasses as I strolled down the street? The Spouse thought it was too cutting toward me in the same way the Rip-Stick story was too cutting about him.
With the deadline for the Christmas and Hanukkah cards bearing down, I suggested that I create something I dubbed, “The Redacted Christmas card.” I’d write some sentences and use a thick Sharpie marker to draw lines through the nonsense, filler text as if I were a government censor. It would go something like this:
“It was at THAT moment, when The Youngest Boy was banned from eating chicken. The rest of the nonsense text would go on for a few lines and be unreadable as it would be covered by a thick, black line. But then, The Eldest Boy, chimed in, establishing why he’s been nicknamed, The Instigator. The quick brown fox jumped . . . now how does the rest of that cliched sentence go, the one my father used to type when he would try out new typewriters? But you had to hand it to The Girl, who, in November, decided to ditch her feminine name and replace it with ‘Nick.’”
I thought a censored Christmas card would be kind of funny (thought it was really just my passive aggressive response to being censored), but The Spouse disagreed, saying, “Maybe five of your friends would think it was funny. Everyone else would be confused.” He said he could envision relatives calling us and asking for an unmarked copy of the story.
Seeing as I found it creatively impossible to concoct an amusing card under such conditions, I opted for no story at all.
But I’m not planning on letting my efforts go to waste. I’m going to post the kids’ Q&A’s here, as well as some of the rejected holiday cards stories, ones that were deemed inappropriate for the family Christmas card. There shall be no redacting here.