Picket Fence Post

November 5, 2009

Three for Thursday: Controversy Over H1N1 Vaccine Availability, Dads Are Important & Parents Shld Back Off Kids’ Homework

Item #1: Controversy Over H1N1 Vaccine Availability

After posting on Facebook the news that this week one of my kids was diagnosed with H1N1 (swine flu), many folks lamented the fact that they’ve been vigorously trying to obtain vaccines for their children but can’t. People are, in a word, pissed.

First of all, the president last week declared that the United States is in a state of emergency when it comes to the swine flu as the media have been hyping the death stats from H1N1 with scary stories of healthy pregnant women and children being fatally stricken with the disease — like the constant, ominus, beating of a drum — and making it seem as though the plague is awaiting us on our front stoops.

Secondly, there’s been an unforeseen production shortage of H1N1 vaccines, vaccines for which the Centers for Disease Control is urging parents of young children and pregnant women to obtain. And, in the midst of this federal-government-declared emergency, there’s currently not enough of the vaccine to go around right now.

Third, another unseemly factor was thrown into the mix this week: The government has been releasing dosages of the hard-to-find H1N1 vaccine to various groups including corporations, a practice they typically utilize to distribute the seasonal flu vaccines every year. However when people read the news that Wall Street banking and trading companies like Goldman Sachs and Citigroup are obtaining doses of H1N1 vaccines (for which the companies had previously ordered from health officials) while other groups like pediatricians and ob/gyns don’t have enough to meet the needs of their high-risk patients, folks get irritated, to put it mildly.

Seeing NBC’s Today Show report below, which says that New York’s Goldman Sachs got as many doses of H1N1 vaccine as an entire hospital (200), you can see how this issue is quickly spiraling into the haves vs the have-nots, or, as the Today Show put it, Wall Street vs Main Street, yet again:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Item #2: Dads Are Important

While this news story falls into the, “Well, yeah, of course, you idiot” category, I found some of the points made in the New York Times’ piece, “Fathers Gain Respect From Experts (And Mothers)” — about how having dads around is important to children — are worth mentioning. The story said that institutionally, dads feel excluded from places where parents and children gather because the physical environment and the practices utilized by staff in such locations are geared toward children and mothers, sending clear signals that taking care of the kiddos is for mothers, not fathers.

“The walls in family resource centers are pink, there are women’s magazines in the waiting room, the mother’s name is on the files, and the home visitor asks for the mother if the father answers the door,” a University of California Berkeley psychology professor told the Times. “It’s like fathers are not there.”

This happens all the time in schools as well when there’s an assumption that the volunteers for school-related tasks will be women, hence the phrase “room mothers.” (I’ve yet to hear anyone invoke the phrase “room fathers.”) One time The Spouse volunteered to be a chaperone for one of our kids’ field trips and, after the chaperones had been selected, a note was sent home saying that I had been among those chosen volunteers to go on the trip, when it was The Spouse’s name that had been submitted.

Additionally, the Times story pointed out that, in order to allow children to benefit from their relationships with their fathers, mothers need to back off and stop micromanaging everything. The paper paraphrased a child psychologist as saying, “Fathers tend to do things different . . . but not in ways that are worse for their children. Fathers do not mother, they father.”

Item #3: Parents Should Back Off Kids’ Homework

Speaking of backing off, syndicated columnist Betsy Hart asserted in a new essay that she doesn’t think it’s necessary for parents to micromanage their children’s homework assignments and drill the children to prepare them for tests, especially in the younger grades. The mother of four believes that her children should learn how to manage their schoolwork, and, when they fail to do so, learn from the consequences fo their failure. An excerpt:

“I worry that if a parent is stressing about [his or her child's] tests and advanced placement in the third grade, these might be the same parents who are literally checking in on a child’s tests and assignments in college on a regular basis. Or even going to job interviews with a grown child after he gets his degree.

. . . Okay, I could just be rationalizing the ‘benign neglect’ that I employ for the most part when it comes to my kids and school. Maybe my children are going to be the ones at a huge disadvantage someday. Perhaps I just don’t have the time to ‘grind through’ a third-grader’s test prep.

But once again the older I get, the more wisdom it turns out my mother had. When it comes to what we do for our kids, she would say, so often less is more.”

7 Comments »

  1. I saw the same story about Wall Street getting the H1N1 before our kids. Another reason I am losing faith in the people running the show.

    Let’s see if I get this right:
    -every parent has been driven crazy with the beating of the “you must get your kid the H1N1 vaccine”
    - the vaccine isn’t available to the majority before the flu season hits,
    - in most cases, unless the child is admitted to the hospital, they’re not even testing to determine if it is H1N1,
    - everyone with flu symptoms at this point is believed to have H1N1 and is being treated as such, but…
    - everyone should still get the shot because they can’t say for sure if you’ve had it, even if you’ve been sick, because they’re NOT testing,
    - the vaccine still isn’t available in large enough quantities for those at risk, like children and pregnant women, but Corporate America gets dibs on it because they asked for it?

    ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!?! And how many of us are walking a fine line with our employers for missing work already with a sick kid? Where is the shield for us? I guarantee before this is over, you’ll see people losing jobs for staying home with sick kids.

    Comment by WorkingMom — November 5, 2009 @ 9:51 pm

  2. Wow. That’s really all I can say. I knew that the vaccine shortage was bad, but not to this extent.

    I am one of the fortunate ones who has already gotten their vaccine as I used to work as a therapist at a local hospital (and am still on their employee list). However, even our pediatrician has not gotten hers and she sees 2-3 cases of it daily. She informed me that pharmacies, such as CVS/Wags might be getting the vaccines before the much-needed doctors offices (specifically pediatrician and OB offices).

    And now I read about the big corporations getting them before the doctors? I am appalled. I have a 4 month old son who I am trying to protect and in order to do so, would like my 2.5 year old and husband to receive the vaccination. Even though we are technically part of the high risk group (because of my youngest’s age), we can’t get an appointment with our local county health department until December 4th. It literally is now a race against the clock - will we contract it before we get the vaccine? More and more people I know are coming down with it, so it’s getting harder and harder to avoid it. Starting to feel as if we are living in a bubble sometimes.

    Thanks for sharing this information. Good to know we are justified in feeling frustrated with the way this entire process is being handled! And thanks for the opportunity to sound off!

    Tamara (aka The UnExperienced Mom)
    http://www.theunexperiencedmom.com

    Comment by Tamara — November 9, 2009 @ 9:34 pm

  3. the H1N1 or Swine Flu virus did put our country in disarray for quite sometime, it is good to know that at least it did not cause so many deaths.

    Comment by Melody — November 22, 2009 @ 9:45 am

  4. My brother got infected with H1N1 or Swine Flu in Mexico. He got a mild fever and luckily he did not die.

    Comment by Jude — January 1, 2010 @ 11:45 pm

  5. If you look at the pandemic of 1977, when H1N1 or Swine Flu re-emerged after a 20 year absence, there is no shift in age-related mortality pattern. The 1977 “pandemic” is, of course, not considered a true pandemic by experts today, for reasons that are not entierely consistent. It certainly was an antigenic shift and not an antigenic drift. As far as I have been able to follow the current events, the most significant factor seems to have been that most people, who were severely affected, were people with other medical conditions.

    Comment by | Acne Treatments Asia — January 4, 2010 @ 10:03 pm

  6. during the height of the H1N1 or Swine Flu epidemic, i was very afraid to get infected with this disease and i wore face mask whenever i got into heavily populated areas.

    Comment by Sheena West — January 18, 2010 @ 12:29 pm

  7. i remember being scared of getting infected by H1N1 during the height of the pandemic. at least two of my classmates got infected by H1N1.

    Comment by Ally — February 3, 2010 @ 9:54 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress

Wicked Local Parents 254 Second Avenue, Needham, Massachusetts 02494
Contact Us | Advertiser Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use
Copyright © 2008 GateHouse Media, Inc. Some Righs Reserved.
Original content available for non-commercial use
under a Creative Commons license, except where noted.
Creative Commons